Arbitration clauses in card agreements: what they mean and how to opt out

4 min read General education, not advice

An arbitration clause says that if you have a legal dispute with your card issuer, a private arbitrator decides it instead of a judge or jury. Many card agreements include one, and many of those also stop you from joining a class action. Some let you reject the clause by sending written notice within a set time after you open the account. The clause itself tells you whether you can and how.

What arbitration means in practice

The clause is about legal claims, such as a dispute over fees the issuer charged or how it handled your account. Disputing a wrong charge on your statement is a separate process you start with the issuer under federal billing error rules.

In arbitration, an arbitrator hears both sides and makes a decision, following the procedures the clause sets out. That decision is generally final. Under the Federal Arbitration Act, a court can set aside an award only on narrow grounds:

  • The award was obtained through corruption, fraud or other improper means.
  • An arbitrator was clearly biased or corrupt.
  • The arbitrator refused to hear relevant evidence, refused a justified delay, or otherwise misbehaved in a way that hurt a party.
  • The arbitrator went beyond their powers.

Disagreeing with the result isn't on that list.

What to look for in the clause

Search your agreement for "arbitration." The section is often long, so read it with these questions in mind:

  1. Which claims does it cover, and does it cover claims against companies working with the issuer?
  2. Does it bar class actions and class arbitration?
  3. Can either side still use small claims court?
  4. Who pays the arbitration fees, and where would a hearing take place?
  5. Can you reject the clause? If so, what's the deadline and where do you send the notice?
  6. Does it keep applying after the account is closed?

If you don't have the agreement handy, our guide to finding a card agreement explains how to get it.

How to opt out, if yours allows it

  1. Find the opt-out instructions in the arbitration section. Note the deadline and the exact address.
  2. Write a short letter that gives your name and address, identifies the account the way the clause asks, and says plainly that you reject the arbitration clause.
  3. Include anything else the clause requires, such as signatures from everyone on the account.
  4. Send it the way the clause says, before the deadline. If it goes by mail, a service with proof of delivery gives you a record.
  5. Keep a copy of the letter and the proof with your agreement.

If you open another card later, check that agreement's clause as well.

Rules that limit arbitration

In 2017 the CFPB issued a rule that would have stopped companies from using arbitration clauses to block class actions. Congress overturned it later that year, so there's no general federal ban on these clauses in card agreements.

Servicemembers are the main exception. Under the Military Lending Act, a lender can't make covered borrowers agree to settle disputes through arbitration, and the law applies to credit cards. It covers active-duty members of the armed forces, Reserve members on active duty, National Guard members mobilized under federal orders for more than 30 days in a row, their spouses, and sometimes their dependents.

Common questions

Can I still take a dispute to small claims court?

Often, yes. Many arbitration clauses let either side bring a claim in small claims court instead. Check your clause for that exception and any limits on it.

Does the Military Lending Act protect my spouse too?

Yes. Spouses of covered servicemembers are covered, and some dependents are as well, so a lender can't require them to agree to arbitration either.

Can I appeal an arbitrator's decision?

Only in limited cases. A court can overturn an award for reasons such as fraud, an arbitrator's clear bias or serious misconduct, but not just because one side thinks the decision was wrong.

The CFPB's credit card agreement database lets you read an issuer's agreements, including any arbitration clause, before you apply.

This guide is general education, not financial advice. Card rates, fees and approval are set by each issuer, so check the issuer's own terms before you apply.

Get the newsletter

Plain-English tips on credit cards and credit, plus card offers from our partners. Free.

More guides