Debt relief scams: fee rules, warning signs and the risks of settlement

5 min read General education, not advice

A debt relief company that sells its service by phone can't charge you anything until it has settled, reduced or changed at least one of your debts and you've made at least one payment under that new deal. A company that wants fees up front, guarantees it can make your debts go away, or tells you to stop paying your creditors without explaining the risks is showing the warning signs the FTC lists.

What counts as debt relief

Under the FTC's Telemarketing Sales Rule, a debt relief service is any program that offers to renegotiate, settle or change what you owe to unsecured creditors or debt collectors, including cutting the balance, the interest rate or fees. Credit card debt is unsecured, so it's covered.

The rule's fee limits and required disclosures apply when the service is sold by phone. That includes calls you make yourself after seeing an ad or getting a mailer or email about debt relief.

When a company can charge a fee

A debt relief company can't ask for or collect any fee until all of these have happened:

  1. It has settled, reduced or otherwise changed the terms of at least one of your debts, under an agreement you've signed.
  2. You've made at least one payment to the creditor or collector under that agreement.
  3. The fee for that debt is either its proportional share of the total fee, based on the debt's size, or a percentage of the amount you saved. If it's a percentage, it has to be the same for every debt.

Here's an example with made-up numbers. You enroll two card debts, $6,000 and $4,000, and the company charges 25% of what you save. It settles the $6,000 debt for $3,600, and you pay it. You saved $2,400, so the fee for that debt is $600. Nothing can be charged on the $4,000 debt until it's settled too.

Rules for the savings account

A program may ask you to put money aside in a special account until there's enough to offer a creditor. The rule allows that only if:

  • The account is at an insured financial institution.
  • You own the money in it, plus any interest.
  • The company running the account isn't owned by, controlled by or affiliated with the debt relief company, and doesn't pay or take referral fees with it.
  • You can leave the program at any time without penalty and get your money back within seven business days, minus only fees the company has properly earned.

What they have to tell you before you sign up

  • How long it will take to get results, and when the company will make a settlement offer to each creditor.
  • How much money you need to save before it makes each offer.
  • If the program depends on you not paying your creditors, that this will likely hurt your credit, that creditors or collectors may sue you or keep collecting, and that fees and interest may raise what you owe.

Risks even when a company follows the rules

The FTC points out that creditors don't have to agree to a settlement. While you're saving up, late fees and interest can grow, late payments can appear on your credit reports, and a creditor can sue. If it wins, it may be able to garnish your wages or put a lien on your home.

Settled debt can also be taxed. The IRS says canceled debt is generally taxable income in the year it's canceled, and the creditor may send you a Form 1099-C. Some exclusions apply, such as being insolvent when the debt was canceled.

Warning signs

  • Fees before any debt is settled, including "setup" or monthly fees.
  • A promise to settle all your debts, or to stop all collection lawsuits.
  • Signing you up without first looking at your finances.
  • Telling you to stop talking to your creditors without explaining what that means.
  • Not telling you the fees, timeline, risks or how much you'll need to save.

Our guide to credit repair scams covers a related pitch: companies that promise to clean up your credit report. The FTC also suggests looking at credit counseling, where a counselor reviews your budget before recommending a plan.

Common questions

Can a debt relief company charge a monthly fee before it settles anything?

Not if it sells by phone. The rule bans any fee until at least one debt is settled or changed and you've made a payment under the new terms.

Will I owe tax on a settled debt?

Possibly. The IRS treats canceled debt as taxable income unless an exception or exclusion applies, such as insolvency. You report the amount for the year the debt was canceled.

What should I do if a company already took fees up front?

Report it to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov and to your state attorney general. If you paid by card, call your card issuer and ask about disputing the charge.

The FTC's guide on how to get out of debt explains debt settlement, its risks and the alternatives.

This guide is general education, not financial advice. Card rates, fees and approval are set by each issuer, so check the issuer's own terms before you apply.

Get the newsletter

Plain-English tips on credit cards and credit, plus card offers from our partners. Free.

More guides